17 messages over 3 pages: 1 2 3
Vlad Trilingual Super Polyglot Senior Member Czechoslovakia foreverastudent.com Joined 6575 days ago 443 posts - 576 votes 2 sounds Speaks: Czech*, Slovak*, Hungarian*, Mandarin, EnglishC2, GermanC2, ItalianC1, Spanish, Russian, Polish, Serbian, French Studies: Persian, Taiwanese, Romanian, Portuguese
| Message 17 of 17 28 June 2011 at 6:12am | IP Logged |
Wow, my last serious entry into this journal was 7 months ago! Time flies so fast.
Maybe it's a good time to review a little to see where I stand with Mandarin at this
point in time.
It's almost unbelievable that I can say this, but I feel my Mandarin is finally getting
somewhere! It's been more than a year and a half since I've been in Taiwan and more
than a year since I've completely changed my approach and I think it has definitely
paid off. When I speak Mandarin now, I am not tired at all, I don't think about
pronunciation and often I can choose from more than a couple of ways of how to say the
same thing. The sentences that I produce - since I repeat what I hear around me, are
structurally Mandarin-spot on and after such a long time, I finally start getting the
gist of the logic of Mandarin and can improvise in situations where I haven't heard or
said similar sentences/sentence structures before. I finished reading a 12 book series
of 死亡筆記本 and towards the end of the series (book 10,11,12), when I got used to the
vocabulary I was reading it almost at natural speed, which made me incredibly happy.
Now I'm reading a fat 400 page detective story (黑暗的回聲) and try to keep a pace of 40
pages a day without a dictionary. Well, see how that goes. I usually understand every
word when it comes to direct speech dialogues in these books. When it comes to
descriptive sections, sometimes I understand every word, sometimes just enough to get
the gist and sometimes I don't get the entire sentence.
When it comes to oral comprehension, when talking to people it happens once every 10
minutes on average that I don't understand a word. I understand TV talk-shows pretty
well, but it depends on the show. Movies are more difficult, but with Chinese subtitles
it's not that bad. News broadcasts are still a problem. I can read newspapers, but the
topic has to be international or something I know a little more about. If it's local
Taiwanese politics, the article is usually full of names of politicians or institutions
making it difficult for me to distinguish what is a name and what is a regular noun
which I don't know the meaning of.
When it comes to writing, since I've been reading so much lately, it's been up a notch,
but still not what I would like it to be. Per paragraph I write I usually have to ask
once or twice to check a sentence structure that I wrote. Usually they are Ok, but
every now and then the still look weird.
Since I dropped my conscious forced attention to tones, my pronunciation has turned out
to be more and more natural and closer to the standard. There still are a couple of
sounds that I am working on - especially the Taiwanese version of sh, ch and zh, since
the way I pronounce it is too soft and I am still looking for the correct position of
the tongue. When it comes to vowels, the one that is a killer for all the foreigners is
the Mandarin "a". Who would've thought. It will give you away as a foreigner on the
phone any time. Maybe it is the height of the neutral tone in 嗎 that should be a lot
lower in 真的嗎 than I used to pronounce it and not the sound it self, but it is this
vowel that I have to work on.
Because of my previous Mandarin instruction (explanation of tones based on graphs and
the use of pinyin), even given my best effort I was pronouncing rather what I saw and
not what I heard so now I am basically working on rebuilding my entire pronunciation
base to make the words sound like they are supposed to and not the way they I was
trying to pronounce them according to tonal graphs.
Also, forgetting is a very big part of my learning process. For instance the fairly
simple word 先生 is not a very frequent word in my daily life actually but a very
frequent word in my Mandarin scholastic life, since it was one of the first words I
learned. After hearing and saying it less and less, I forgot the details of how I used
to pronounce it and when my Taiwanese friend suddenly said it, I noticed a whole lot of
things. For instance that I used to pronounce the 生 almost in a neutral tone and
didn't give it it's proper length, that I used to pronounce the "ia" sound in 先 as if
it were merged together whereas the "i" and the "a" should be quite distinct and fused
through a "y" but still very distinct and this small discovery led me to upgrade my pronunciation in all other "-ie" , "ian", "-eng" finals. Fortunately I make these small
discoveries all the time and do this little "word sculpting" to make my pronunciation
better.
I dropped pinyin a long time ago as well and I don't feel "bound" anymore by it since I
also forgot the associations between the pinyin writing and the way I used to pronounce
words. Individual words are easier for me to "sculpt" to the way they are supposed to
sound, because I can "forget" my wrong pronunciation of them faster and thus upgrade
them to a more standard one, but the most basic of words or combinations, like 我, 我有,
不是, 不要 and so on.. I use them a hundred times every day, so it's difficult for me to
"forget" the details of their pronunciation and then notice why exactly I was
pronouncing them wrong.
All in all I am quite happy with my progress and according to the forum classification
I feel like I am approaching advanced fluency, but I'm still not there. For advanced
fluency I should be able to turn on the TV at any given time and be able to understand
what they are talking about just as if it were English or Slovak, I should be able to
read novels almost at natural speed, I should be finally satisfied with my
pronunciation and while speaking I should be able to play around with expressions in
every situation, having at least 2-3 possibilities to express the same thing at any
given moment. When I get there, if I ever get there, maybe I will finally be able to
compete with big boys like 大山 and the rest :))
1 person has voted this message useful
|
This discussion contains 17 messages over 3 pages: << Prev 1 2 3 If you wish to post a reply to this topic you must first login. If you are not already registered you must first register
You cannot post new topics in this forum - You cannot reply to topics in this forum - You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum - You cannot create polls in this forum - You cannot vote in polls in this forum
This page was generated in 0.1094 seconds.
DHTML Menu By Milonic JavaScript
|