Register  Login  Active Topics  Maps  

Bande dessinée + FNAC

 Language Learning Forum : Specific Languages Post Reply
18 messages over 3 pages: 1 2 3  Next >>
Anomi
Newbie
Austria
Joined 4450 days ago

20 posts - 26 votes
Speaks: English*
Studies: French

 
 Message 1 of 18
25 February 2013 at 10:54pm | IP Logged 
Hi everyone, I hope this is the in the right forum!

My target language is French and currently I've been out of classes for almost a year,
and won't start classes again until this upcoming September and I've been looking for
reading material that would suit my reading level and interests.

So, my question is about other 'bande dessinée' other then Astérix and Tintin.

I've read a few volumes of Tintin and one of Astérix (which I found much harder) but
neither really interests me *that* much in terms of storyline.
There are volumes of Tintin I found intriguing, but so far I've only picked up ones
that I've seen really great reviews for (ie. Tintin au Tibet)
I did enjoy what I've read only because there's a sense of accomplishment you get when
you understand something new, but it can be a real study session for me to look up a
lot of unknown vocabulary and I'd like something a little less dense just to flip
through when I have downtime.

I've been looking at other BDs aimed more at teenage girls (I'm 18, but these books
seem to aimed at 13-15 year olds) such as Lou!, Les Nombrils and Tamara and I was
wondering if people had reviews of any of these titles, or similar titles. Even though
they might sometimes exceed my reading level, I can usually get the gist and I like the
art style so I'm hoping that will also compel me to keep reading.
The main reason for reading is just to stimulate my mind and get myself thinking in
French, which I'm sure it will accomplish.

Also, the BDs listed vary in origin from Belgium, France and also Quebéc. Do you think
this will mess me up? I figure they're all written in more colloquial text, which I'm
looking forward to, but maybe the cross-cultural influence will leave me a little
garbled up ? I mean in learning new vocabulary and then using that in conversation. Not
in my own understanding of the text.

I'm also wondering if I'll pick up outdated expressions by reading Tintin, Gaston or
other older BDs, or maybe the good vocabulary will greatly outweigh the bad ?

Lastly, do you guys ever order from FNAC? They have so many great French-language
options as it's a French store and I've been able to order really cheap books there
recently (Old folktales for 1-2 euros each, which are familiar to me so they're fun to
flip through as well) The downside is, of course, the shipping (for me at least, as I'm
in Canada). Do any of you know of Quebec bookstores with websites that I could maybe
order from instead? The french selection at the chain stores around here are slim to
none, but when I visited Montréal and Quebéc City I loved to browse through local
bookstores. That's how I got most of the BDs I have at the moment.

I think I've seen other topics touching on this but I couldn't find them again when I
searched so I thought I should just ask again. So I apologize if this is any sort of
repeat, and also for the long post. I kept thinking of stuff! ;)
2 persons have voted this message useful





emk
Diglot
Moderator
United States
Joined 5291 days ago

2615 posts - 8806 votes 
Speaks: English*, FrenchB2
Studies: Spanish, Ancient Egyptian
Personal Language Map

 
 Message 2 of 18
25 February 2013 at 11:48pm | IP Logged 
Anomi wrote:
I've been looking at other BDs aimed more at teenage girls (I'm 18, but these books
seem to aimed at 13-15 year olds) such as Lou!, Les Nombrils and Tamara and I was
wondering if people had reviews of any of these titles, or similar titles.


I don't know any BDs aimed at teenage girls. But you can find a lot of BD reviews in my log, and I try to note which are easy reads and which are more challenging. Do check out the review Persepolis, which is about a young girl growing up during the Iranian revolution. It's packed full of modern conversational French.

Also, although it's not a BD, the French dubs of Buffy and Angel are extremely good, and they've always appealed to a primarily female audience. You might not be ready for these yet, but they were my first real TV show in French. You can find transcripts of nearly all the episodes online, too. You can often find box sets on Amazon.fr.

Anomi wrote:
Also, the BDs listed vary in origin from Belgium, France and also Quebéc. Do you think
this will mess me up? I figure they're all written in more colloquial text, which I'm
looking forward to, but maybe the cross-cultural influence will leave me a little
garbled up ? I mean in learning new vocabulary and then using that in conversation.


This shouldn't be a problem. Written French is pretty much standard throughout the world. I've occasionally encountered one or two characters in BD who used some local slang, but it's usually really obvious. You can generally trust your common sense.

Anomi wrote:
I'm also wondering if I'll pick up outdated expressions by reading Tintin, Gaston or
other older BDs, or maybe the good vocabulary will greatly outweigh the bad ?


You should be fine. Tintin is often a little formal, and uses nous where most French speakers would use on. But as long as you read a lot, you'll be perfectly fine. Just don't try to swear like Captain Haddock unless you're joking. :-)

Anomi wrote:
Lastly, do you guys ever order from FNAC? They have so many great French-language
options as it's a French store and I've been able to order really cheap books there
recently (Old folktales for 1-2 euros each, which are familiar to me so they're fun to
flip through as well) The downside is, of course, the shipping (for me at least, as I'm
in Canada). Do any of you know of Quebec bookstores with websites that I could maybe
order from instead? The french selection at the chain stores around here are slim to
none, but when I visited Montréal and Quebéc City I loved to browse through local
bookstores. That's how I got most of the BDs I have at the moment.


Your best bets are probably Renauld-Bray (either online or in the store) and Amazon.ca. You can also read lots of BDs online at Izneo for very reasonable prices. And sometimes it's actually cheapest to buy BDs on Amazon.fr and have them shipped. Just log in with your regular Amazon name and password and everything will work normally.

I think that BDs are one of the coolest things about learning French. They contain lots of dialog, and their illustrations give you a handy comprehension boost allowing you to learn lots of vocabulary from context. And some of the BDs out there are really, really good. If you discover some cool BDs, please feel free to post a log and tell us about them! :-)
2 persons have voted this message useful



Anomi
Newbie
Austria
Joined 4450 days ago

20 posts - 26 votes
Speaks: English*
Studies: French

 
 Message 3 of 18
26 February 2013 at 12:26am | IP Logged 
Thank you so much for the extensive reply!

emk wrote:
I don't know any BDs aimed at teenage girls.


I guess I shouldn't say I'd like BDs aimed only at teenage girls, but simply that I
want to try something different than Tintin and Asterix. I think I'm mostly looking for
a slice-of-life type BD, which I think a lot of 'tween' media in general is focused
around.
Something like Calvin and Hobbes would do just as well :)
I just don't really want to be bogged down by too much history and instead want to
learn more about current culture, especially since anything too dense is likely to go
beyond my level.
I'll still be going through Tintin and (maybe) Astérix, but I'd like some other
options.

emk wrote:
...you can find a lot of BD reviews in my
log, and I try to note which are easy reads and which are more challenging. Do
check out the review Persepolis, which is about a young girl growing up during
the Iranian revolution.


I will definitely be looking through your BD reviews, you seem to have covered a wide
range of genres/topics that could be really useful :)
I have been looking at Persepolis but I wonder if it's better to try and read it or
watch it ? Since it has won many awards and I'm interested in French-language movies as
well.
I suppose if I like it, I could do both o:


emk wrote:
I think that BDs are one of the coolest things about learning French.They
contain lots of dialog, and their illustrations give you a handy comprehension boost
allowing you to learn lots of vocabulary from context. And some of the BDs out there
are really, really good. If you discover some cool BDs, please feel free to post a log
and tell us about them! :-)



I totally agree with you about BDs being something really awesome about French. They
can be so beneficial to learning the language as well as tasting the culture. I'll
definitely share if I find any keepers!


Additionally, this may be of interest to you (it was to me);

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cuXmovtMd1U

That's a 'video promo' for the BD Zombillénium, which I think I'll be checking out.
But that whole channel is the same type of thing, video promos for BDs published under
SPIROU

Edited by Anomi on 26 February 2013 at 1:23am

2 persons have voted this message useful





emk
Diglot
Moderator
United States
Joined 5291 days ago

2615 posts - 8806 votes 
Speaks: English*, FrenchB2
Studies: Spanish, Ancient Egyptian
Personal Language Map

 
 Message 4 of 18
26 February 2013 at 2:43am | IP Logged 
Anomi wrote:
I think I'm mostly looking for a slice-of-life type BD, which I think a lot of 'tween' media in general is focused around.
Something like Calvin and Hobbes would do just as well :)

For comic-style BDs, check out BlogsBD and the review of À boire et à manger in my log (which links to the free online version). For "slice of life", you might be interested in Immigrants, a collection 13 short stories about the lives of people who've moved to France. They include some really remarkable tales about life in Africa and elsewhere, and about integrating into French society.

You might or might not like Mondes d'Aldébaran. It's a 5-volume story about a young man and woman growing up on another planet. The science fiction part of the tale is great juvenile SF with lots of "sense of wonder" moments and weird alien lifeforms. The coming-of-age story is rather average Young Adult fiction with a few annoying moments. These books are interesting because they include lots of natural conversation, and they're some of the easier BDs I've read.

Again, you can find sample pages and reviews for all of these in my log.

Anomi wrote:
I have been looking at Persepolis but I wonder if it's better to try and read it or
watch it ? Since it has won many awards and I'm interested in French-language movies as
well.
I suppose if I like it, I could do both o:

I've got the BD and I plan to pick up the movie the next time I see it for sale. :-) Almost a year ago, my tutor e-mailed me a scan of this page and I had to buy the book immediately:



That's pretty much what actual French sarcasm sounds like, at least to my non-native ears. Look especially at the contractions and how the questions are formed. This is way closer to spoken French than half the dialog in Tintin.

Anomi wrote:
Additionally, this may be of interest to you (it was to me);

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cuXmovtMd1U

That's a 'video promo' for the BD Zombillénium, which I think I'll be checking out.
But that whole channel is the same type of thing, video promos for BDs published under
SPIROU

That looks really amusing. :-) Thank you for the link!
2 persons have voted this message useful



microsnout
TAC 2010 Winner
Senior Member
Canada
microsnout.wordpress
Joined 5230 days ago

277 posts - 553 votes 
Speaks: English*
Studies: French

 
 Message 5 of 18
26 February 2013 at 4:18am | IP Logged 
There is also the store Librairie Marché du Livre which I believe
specializes in and has a larger BD selection than Renauld-Bray. You can order online or visit the store at the
corner of Boul de Maisonneuve and Rue Saint-Hubert in Montreal.

Edited by microsnout on 26 February 2013 at 4:19am

2 persons have voted this message useful



Anomi
Newbie
Austria
Joined 4450 days ago

20 posts - 26 votes
Speaks: English*
Studies: French

 
 Message 6 of 18
26 February 2013 at 4:21am | IP Logged 
emk wrote:
You might or might not like Mondes d'Aldébaran. It's a 5-volume story
about a young man and woman growing up on another planet. The science fiction part of
the tale is great juvenile SF with lots of "sense of wonder" moments and weird alien
lifeforms. The coming-of-age story is rather average Young Adult fiction with a few
annoying moments. These books are interesting because they include lots of natural
conversation, and they're some of the easier BDs I've read.


My only worry with sci-fi is that there will be a lot of niche vocabulary, but I'm sure
it's worth the look since I do like that type of thing in English :)

EDIT: Actually, I had a look at Mondes d'Aldébaran and if the page you scanned
is any indication, it might be worth a glance as well! Thanks for all the hot tips :)

emk wrote:
I've got the BD and I plan to pick up the movie the next time I see it for
sale. :-) Almost a year ago, my tutor e-mailed me a scan of this page and I had to buy
the book immediately:



That's pretty much what actual French sarcasm sounds like, at least to my non-native
ears. Look especially at the contractions and how the questions are formed. This is way
closer to spoken French than half the dialog in Tintin.


Aha! That's actually great. I wish I could read the next page now too :) I'll put it on
my list to pick up.
If you do see the movie, will you post a review on your log? If so, I'll have to look
out for it.

I also read on your log about you wanting to pick up more documentaries in french,
which is something I've been looking into as well. I'm very into all things science
(and the vocabulary would be useful for my job as well as everyday life). I already own
the English-language Planet Earth and it's expensive so I rather not pick up another
copy, but I'm always looking out for other BBC stuff.
I've been considering picking up Chimpanzees in french, I saw it in theater and I
*love* anything about great apes. Did you find anything noteworthy in your search?

microsnout wrote:

There is also the store Librairie Marché du Livre which I believe
specializes in and has a larger BD selection than Renauld-Bray. You can order online or
visit the store at the
corner of Boul de Maisonneuve and Rue Saint-Hubert in Montreal.

Awesome! I'll definitely check it out online, unfortunately I don't think I'll be back
to Montréal very soon, which is a shame since I love it so much ):

DOUBLE EDIT: I just checked out that link, it's really great! It's nice to just
see
BDs, even just to get titles to search on other sites.

Edited by Anomi on 26 February 2013 at 6:20am

1 person has voted this message useful





songlines
Pro Member
Canada
flickr.com/photos/cp
Joined 4968 days ago

729 posts - 1056 votes 
Speaks: English*
Studies: French
Personal Language Map

 
 Message 7 of 18
27 February 2013 at 6:16am | IP Logged 
Anomi, I'd like to second Emk's recommendation of
http://www.izneo.com/ .   I've been a fan of the site ever since Geoffw
mentioned it on these forums a number of weeks ago.

-They have a huuge selection of digital ("numerique" in French) BDs, conveniently organized by genre: Adventure,
thriller, fantasy, horror, historical, etc... The 3,600 figure in the drop down menu on their site may not be
accurate, as I think titles which fall into more than one genre are "double-counted". But still, they have a
significant number of titles.

-You can either pay for permanent access (streamed files, not downloads), or temporary access (1.99 Euro/$2.70
Can) rental for 10 days. There's also a subscription offer, whereby you have access to something like 15(?) BDs
for a month. (If you download the app to your iPad, you can read the BDs offline- until the expiry date of your
rental period, anyway.)

- Many of the titles have a "first 5 pages" free preview - a tremendously useful feature.

- The titles I've previewed are automatically saved in a tab of their own (under "Premières planches") in my iPad
Izneo app., and function as something of a "wishlist", either for future rentals, or for me to check if the library
has physical copies of any of the books. (There doesn't seem to be a way of editing things in "premières
planches", so it's just as well that I like them there.)

- Tremendous savings: $27 per volume for a printed version at somewhere like La Maison Presse Internationale,
vs. $2.70 for a ten-day rental? Much as I love physical books, the savings are are just too good to ignore. (I
probably will buy some BDs eventually, but they'll be ones I'll have read, and know I want to own.)

I do have a few wishlists of my own regarding Izneo:
- Bookmarks. There doesn't seem to be a way of bookmarking pages. It would seem easy enough to just
remember the page, but I sometimes read both English and French editions in tandem, and bookmarks
would help me to keep things straight.

-Highlighting/underlining. I can do this with my other e-books, and wish I could with the Izneo books. Granted,
the vocabulary-learning needs of French-language learners are probably not high on Izneo's list of priorities,
so...

- Built in dictionaries. Ditto.

Anyway, check out the site. You'll find many of the titles that Emk, Quique and others have
mentioned.

One more suggestion: Have you tried getting any BDs through your public library?

I don't know which city you live in, but - if your library system doesn't have them - you could try seeing if you
can get some titles from inter-library loan. (Check first to see if there's a fee; and if so, how much.)    

For example, a keyword search in the catalogue for my library*, Toronto Public Library, under the terms French
graphic books
, yields 665 titles which circulate, of which approx one-
third are adult, one-third teen, and one-third children's. (Don't use the "bandes dessinées" heading: it's too
narrow, and will limit your results drastically down to a couple of dozen books.)

*Also my employer, but I'm not posting this on company time or under its auspices.

Happy reading!


Edited by songlines on 27 February 2013 at 6:17am

3 persons have voted this message useful





emk
Diglot
Moderator
United States
Joined 5291 days ago

2615 posts - 8806 votes 
Speaks: English*, FrenchB2
Studies: Spanish, Ancient Egyptian
Personal Language Map

 
 Message 8 of 18
27 February 2013 at 5:11pm | IP Logged 
Anomi wrote:
My only worry with sci-fi is that there will be a lot of niche vocabulary, but I'm sure it's worth the look since I do like that type of thing in English :)


Looking back over your questions, it seems like you might be a little worried about accidentally getting too much exposure to the "wrong" kind of French. Is this the case? I totally understand this concern, because it used to bother me a lot.

If so, I have some good news, based on a year of reading: Almost anything you pick up will be 99% normal French. Maybe 1% will be words like "airlock" or "magic wand", but hey, who doesn't love a few fun words like that? :-)

Here's how I think of it: There's three main kinds of French, and they're all important.

1) "Newspaper" French. This is what usually gets taught in school.

2) Narrative French. This is the same as newspaper French, except it uses the passé simple and it's used in virtually all fiction books for adults and children.

3) Spoken French. This is a subtly different beast than written French. Nous is replaced by on, ne gets dropped a lot, and the grammar has a different rhythm, as in: C'est quoi, ces chaussures de punk ?

At least for me, the biggest problem was finding enough good sources of (3), because I needed it to understand French TV and conversations between native speakers. I tried avoiding (2) for a while, because people kept telling me the passé simple was a "literary" tense. But I couldn't escape it if I wanted to read actual books. :-)

Anyway, after I had a read a bunch of books, it was pretty obvious which kind of French to use when. The trick wasn't narrowing my reading down to single kind of "good" French, but rather just reading all kinds of interesting stuff. Seriously, even a French rap song like MC Solaar's Clic Clic is loaded with useful vocabulary about current events.

Consider this as encouragement to go read or watch anything that amuses you and not worry about what kind of French it contains. :-)


2 persons have voted this message useful



This discussion contains 18 messages over 3 pages: 2 3  Next >>


Post ReplyPost New Topic Printable version Printable version

You cannot post new topics in this forum - You cannot reply to topics in this forum - You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum - You cannot create polls in this forum - You cannot vote in polls in this forum


This page was generated in 0.3750 seconds.


DHTML Menu By Milonic JavaScript
Copyright 2024 FX Micheloud - All rights reserved
No part of this website may be copied by any means without my written authorization.